Anyone who played any beloved third-party NES game:
Oh, that's cute! 😏
Edit: Just so we're clear, I'm poking fun here, I like Demon/Dark Souls just fine.
but waay too many games get compared to them as though they're the first game with ball-retracting difficulty, lmao.
I can tell you've never beaten Malenia. I hear there's a Teletubbies battle royale MMO in the works for true gamers like you. ;)
Isshin from Sekiro would probably be a better example of a tough, consistent FromSoft boss. Malena is very build specific. Friends who had heavier builds and where used to blocking suffered. I've run dex through the extended franchise, and she melted.
I still find the FromSoft type of difficulty, Sekiro included, more manageable than something like Ninja Gaiden. They're mostly about pattern recognition - learning a moveset and responding accordingly. Not easy by any means, but generally a matter of patience. Ninja Gaiden, especially on Master Ninja, is about split second, highly contextual decision making against a mob of more aggressive enemies.
Souls games are mostly RPGs over Action games like Ninja Gaiden, which means build and item usage will trump skill for a lot of the fights. Its why they just straight up disabled Poise by the time of 3 to try and balance back.
Its also why Sekiro, which offers you minimal options besides the blade, is so much harder than the rest. You have little option but to get good and the game literally gives you a massive handicap for its entire duration (the Charm) that it doesn't even tell you about until you beat it just to help you do so.
Its also their best game but way too underrated because it is way harder than the rest without any cheese available from summoning or overleveling.
Agreed on all points.
The comparison was more on a cognitive level though. Even when disregarding the RPG mechanics, most encounters require very little thinking.
Engaging large groups of mob enemies is discouraged by design. No-lock helps, marginally, but at some point damage is guaranteed by way of AI design and attack/recovery times.
Boss movesets aren't especially complex and are well telegraphed. Once learned, most From bosses are just a matter of responding to cues on time - where timing is the primary difficulty factor.
Isshin was a decent counterpoint - including 4 movesets during the course of the fight. Morgott, in Elden Ring, proved more difficult than many of the popular "hard bosses" during a no-damage no-summon boss run due to the depth of his moveset and the relative complexity of the move triggers. Even then, against a single enemy, it can all be predicted/influenced by the player.
In NG, by way of the number of enemies and the intricacy of the combat system, there really is no preparing for a fight and it takes a lot of quick thinking to excel. Enemies punish poor positioning, but also too much or too little movement. Enemies fatally punish excessive blocking, but it is required to delay essence absorption. Attack chains and enemy type influence essence drop. Essence is essential for quickly thinning large groups, as well as restoring ki and health. I could go on, but my point is despite the largely unparalleled speed of the game, harder difficulties are essentially hyper-violent chess.
Its a problem with a lot of games, in which eventually the difficulty turns it from a game you play into a game you memorize. So you often just bash your head against it until muscle memory makes you do the moves exactly in the only way that could possibly get you through.
Its almost like turning the game into a speedrunner strategy, but its the required play.
Which is the point where I do think that Souls game's difficulty usually hits the correct level, wherein you have a solid chance to one shot most bosses when you see them simply by being careful and thoughtful to your timing. Most people won't, but its something a lot of "uber difficult" and even Soulslike games lack.
Elden Ring is the only odd on in that regard, as its delayed attack and insane tracking means you can't really recover without prior knowledge on the boss and his attacks. Its almost Dark Souls 2 level at times.
I’ve got hundreds of hours into the souls series, Bloodborne and Elden Ring included, but I’ve bounced off Sekiro at least half a dozen times. For me, it’s the setting and the fixed protagonist. I like medieval fantasy and cosmic horror, and I like being able to create my own character.
I do fully intend to get around to Sekiro eventually.
It doesn't help that Sekiro takes a bit before it really gets moving. You start out with so little healing and missing major parts of your kit, like the Mikiri, that it also doesn't feel super good to play until after the first zone or so.
Like, once you hit and beat the boss at the top of the castle is when it actually feels like the game comes together and then its only up from there.
Isn't Malenia easiest with a heavy build? You just go upgrade some huge weapons with double colossal and can out trade her, because she's balanced around small windows of opportunity.
You do have to dodge her sword dance, but she's a low poise and relatively low range boss, and both of those are best exploited by heavy builds. You just can't block.
The windows are tight, but if you're good at parrying most of her moveset is punishable and bleed procs wreck her. Waterfowl dance isn't that hard to avoid; Trivial if you have distance enough to run.
I had an easy time. Friends who rolled heavy had a hard time. Haven't played a heavy/shield build since it ruined my first DS1 playthrough, so can't comment beyond that frame of reference.