Pompeii (where the skin of the people is WHITE)
(www.dailymail.co.uk)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (30)
sorted by:
First of all, Islam doesn't arrive anywhere in Greece until nearly two thousand years after the Bronze Age ends, so you might as well describe that as a "post Cambrian Period invasion" if you're going to be that off in time.
And the MENA admixture was already addressed. That's why on the PCA chart I linked to Greeks are slightly closer in genetic distance to modern MENA populations now compared to other European peoples.
On that note, just because a certain people invade another doesn't mean they wipe out the native population or even change it much (although sometime they do). Rome for example left almost no genetic legacy in Britain despite ruling it for centuries.
Again, modern Greeks are indeed significantly like their ancient ancestors.
First of all, take at look at figure 1 in your study genius, it doesn’t say what you think it does. Secondly, you brought up the Bronze Age, what’s funny is the average modern Greek is only 31% mycenaean genetically. Is that your standard of “significantly like their ancestors”?
Greeks have always had higher admixture with Anatolians and other Arabic peoples. Like this pca shows. https://thuletide.files.wordpress.com/2023/07/pca-west-eurasia.jpg?w=953
What’s funny is you came barging in, proved yourself wrong, and did so spectacularly!
I didn't "bring up the Bronze Age" the Bronze Age era was already in question since we're talking about ancient Greece, which starts in the Bronze Age.
I already stated they have MENA admixture. This was never denied. Why are you stating my OWN argument at me like its a "gotcha"?
And Anatolians aren't an Arab people. Anatolian in that study doesn't mean what you think it means.That PCA chart is showing the ancient genetic lineage of modern Greeks and their distance from those ancestors. In actual fact, Ii doesn't mean what YOU think it means. Again, nothing to do with Arabs in this case.
I will restate your own argument verbatim:
In actual reality, stated plain as day:
QED. Take the L and move on. I'm done with you.