I hate Baldwin but I agree with you. If this is truly an accident, ruining two lives isn't really the way to go. I think he should lose in civil court and owe money to the estate of the person he killed but criminal charges are a bit much even if they are technically legally deserved. I just put myself in his shoes and realize it's something I might have done. If I did it I wouldn't want this punishment so not a good punishment from my perspective. The real person at fault is the person who handed him the gun. That's their job and their one and only job to make sure the gun is safe when they hand it to Baldwin.