Both are rule violations for the same exact reason.

Well, I don't like the disproportionate influence Jews, Gays, Women, Americans, Zionists, Globalists, or Blacks have. Simple as.

Context clues are not mind reading.

Perhaps, but it's still a terrible basis for moderation.

And I don't care that you don't care. I'm not going to willfully chose to be ignorant.

There you go again. I'm not asking you to be "ignorant" or "retarded," I'm telling you to stop be a censorious and nonsensical jannie, when there's no reason. If this was Reddit, sure, do those things to dodge the damn admins. But we're not on Reddit.

I know what words mean, and I know that an ideology has tenets.

Congrats. You're still reading things into it that aren't always there, and that's not fair, and that's not free speech.

R16 is a stupid rule, and always will be.

I'm not going to pretend that: "We should kill every fucking nigger" isn't really what the writer means unless he explicitly tells me what he means by "kill" "every" and "nigger".

Once again going off topic, yay.

I have eyes of which to see, and ears of which to hear. I will not blind and deafen myself to reality.

Oh just stop.

...I still have to decide whether or not they are lying to me

NO. You have to decide whether or not they're BREAKING THE RULES.