You’re attacking an argument I never made. The only thing I said is that this is a clear, obvious exaggeration, and that leading with a clear, obvious exaggeration makes you look wrong. I might question exactly how accurate the ratios in your analogy are, but as I already said, I am willing to entertain the idea that Feminism is inordinately influenced or created by Jews. The problem is, that is not the claim that was made and it is not the claim I am taking issue with. It is also not a claim this meme does anything to support—as another user pointed out, there is a massive list of notable non-Jwish feminists. If this infographic explained why and how the figures chosen shaped or influenced feminism more than their non-Jewish counterparts, that would be something, but again, that is not what this says. What this says is an exaggeration.
If someone says “drinking water kills you,” and then they clarify that they mean “inhaling water kills you,” those are two very different points, and the second point is not wrong. Unfortunately, they already look like an idiot because they led with the first statement, and defending the two statements as being identical doesn’t help.
You’re attacking an argument I never made. The only thing I said is that this is a clear, obvious exaggeration, and that leading with a clear, obvious exaggeration makes you look wrong. I might question exactly how accurate the ratios in your analogy are, but as I already said, I am willing to entertain the idea that Feminism is inordinately influenced or created by Jews. The problem is, that is not the claim that was made and it is not the claim I am taking issue with. It is also not a claim this meme does anything to support—as another user pointed out, there is a massive list of notable non-Jwish feminists. If this infographic explained why and how the figures chosen shaped or influenced feminism more than their non-Jewish counterparts, that would be something, but again, that is not what this says. What this says is an exaggeration.
If someone says “drinking water kills you,” and then they clarify that they mean “inhaling water kills you,” those are two very different points, and the second point is not wrong. Unfortunately, they already look like an idiot because they led with the first statement, and defending the two statements as being identical doesn’t help.