Either The Suffering or Gauntlet from the burnt remain of Midway games, especially to stop whatever garbage that Gauntlet game on Steam is from being the final game in the series.

Or Condemned from Monolith, since they seem to have abandoned it. Which is a shame because it has some of the greatest First Person Melee gameplay ever made, a game where light/dark is more than just an annoying setpiece, and the only multiplayer I've played where the other player's fear is an actual weapon in your arsenal.

Like, its almost amusing how people get so caught up on the story getting silly at the end that they ignored everything else about the game to the point where it got buried. Helping the trend and proving to devs that gameplay should always be second to story going forward right as the "story game" thing starting taking off.