I've been trying to put together a playlist of accidental self owns by Big Media(TM) where they tried to make music slamming those on the right, but ended up making something catchy and being embraced by the very people they're railing against.
Two particular examples I found were Bad Religion's "The Kids Are Alt-Right"
Lyrics: https://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/badreligion/thekidsarealtright.html
And a song from Far Cry 5 called "Keep Your Rifle by Your Side"
Lyrics: https://genius.com/Dan-romer-keep-your-rifle-by-your-side-lyrics
In the former, BR tries to paint the right as a cult (who doesn't these days) but it's hard to take seriously when the lyrics are:
We love God, We love our women, We love tradition, We love kin, We've got shiny new tools, For ancient impulses, That we can't even understand, So if you feel alone, And downtrodden, There's an elixir for your ills
So a bunch of people who feel alone and downtrodden found a group willing to accept them? Well that's not so different than the left in many cases. But they also love tradition and family? Personally, I find it hard to take any of that negatively.
In the latter, for context, the song was written by the in game doomsday cult, but if you're like me and are familiar with Ruby Ridge and Waco the lyrics hit kind of different. Essentially, the group sings about how the government will keep coming after them and it is their duty to defend themselves, their families, and their land by force. It does have a religious tinge to it but not exactly something that makes me want to dislike them. The video on YT has 2.3 million views when everything else in the album is sub 1 mill and the comments are absolutely flooded with people agreeing with the sentiments in the song. And it's catchy as fuck.
Anyway, if any of you have found something similar or have something to add, I'd love to hear it.
I've been trying to come up with a name for this phenomenon.
The best example is always Alan Moore creating Rorschach, a character he comically believed to be a reprehensible caricature of conservatism. In reality, Moore is so far left that he has become disconnected from ordinary morality, and he subsequently cannot understand why people identify and agree with his strawman. By pure delusion, he accidentally created a conservative paragon.
A similar thing happened more recently with Red Skull. They turned him into a mainstream anti-immigration caricature, complete with contemporary anti-immigration screed, but most of the people who actually read his "cruel words" found them to be eminently rationally. Turns out you can't just attribute the ideas of your political enemies to a comic book villain and expect people to automatically reject those ideas based on your new chosen "source".
Again, I'm not sure what to call this phenomenon. Maybe the Moore Paradox.
Well barring anything else, calling it the Moore Paradox sounds excellent.
Ror is also a ripoff of Steve Dtko's Mr. A
Jerkass Has A Point