[Off Topic History] The Fall of Civilizations
(www.youtube.com)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (9)
sorted by:
Never apologize for posting good history content. Unless you're a history PhD you probably don't know nearly enough world history. I certainly don't, and I'm not sure I trust what I do "know".
History focuses a lot of the "fall" of civilizations for obvious reasons. I wish it accompanied this discussion with an analysis of attributes which correlate to failing civilizations and attempted to find civilizations that had some/all of those attributes but managed to not fail. It's all well and good to say why a civilization failed, but it would seem that the most important reason for studying failed civilizations would be to prevent yours from failing; so having examples where you could say "90% of civilizations with these attributes failed within 100 years; this civilization had all of them, but after they did X, Y, and Z they no longer had attributes A, B, and C; and survived another 500 years" would be extremely useful.
Maybe this is studied, but it's not nearly as publicized as "failures".
The risk with that kind of search is that people tend to find what they set out to find, and it's very hard to eliminate that kind of bias and pattern seeking altogether.