The other game in that category now is Sekiro, funny enough, despite all the cliched claims about its lack of replay value.

Sekiro has pretty weak replay value immediately other than just dabbing on bosses with your mastered skills.

But going back every few years and watching yourself clear the rust off and get the "groove" back is an irreplaceable feeling. Its impossible to really quantify, but eventually everything just slides into place and you begin playing a rhythm game instead of an action one and it feels amazing.

My only complaint is that of all the From games it has the worst early game that teeters into "unfair" simply because of your lack of healing and crucial skills (like Mikiri) and the need to go out and grind out a few mini-bosses and trash mobs before you are really prepared to tackle most challenges. It flows pretty decently your first time through because you are expected to die and rekill a lot of mobs, as well as explore every nook, but on replay its noticeable.

Though I imagine the boss gauntlet solves most of that, but I've not interacted with it anytime I've gone back.