I'm curious what you guys wanted to play and disappointed. For instance I hate BG3 but I expected it to be exactly how it turned out so I can't be disappointed in it.
My top disappointment was Dark Envoy, it's an RPG made by Event Horizon the guys that did Tower of Time, I like Tower of Time and I recommend it but Dark Envoy is just boring. The story is uninteresting and predictable, dialogue is just awful, it's the equivalent of punishing high school students to do a play they don't want to and are given the barebones of a play. Combat is repetitive and the game is very easy on hard. Except graphics Tower of Time is miles ahead Dark Envoy. The pros, the game is not woke.
Another disappointment was Total War: Warhammer 3, It came out in 2022 but I only played it last year. I did not complete the main campaign and I can't say I like the new factions or the new siege combat. I think is a step down from 2.
It was Baldurs Gate 3 for me, besides all of the controversies behind it the only fun aspect of the entire game was the world and the combat.
In any RPG the writing is paramount and in BG3 it was mediocre for the majority of it, the best part was Act 2 but that was stupidly short. At some points it was just absolutely insufferable, especially when you add VA's for all sorts of characters which purely just felt like quotas into the mix.
Act 2 was definitely the best. First act was decent but it had some issue and third act where you should get some big reveals was dumb.