I do not believe for an instant that you believe the nihilists are right (that nothing is fundamentally moral or immoral). You wouldn't be here if you did.
i know we as humans made it up
If we "made it up" then the nihilists are right.
Look, this is a CHOICE. If you "know" morality is made up, then all your feelings about what is right and wrong are just you. If you "know" some things are fundamentally right or wrong, then that has to transcend you in order to be projected onto others, it can't just be something made up.
It is YOUR CHOICE to acknowledge a higher source of moral truth in order to give your moral judgements greater weight than your own disapproval. Only the divine can transcend you and encompass your enemies.
can i not already project my morals unto people already?
Yes, but the result will never be more than kratocracy.
Its a distinction between:
"The utter certainty that there will never be an end to violence because it's all against all."
"The unlikely but theoretically possible future where there could be an end to violence because one moral (one divine) has prevailed and all (who remain) abide by it."
As long as it's literally just you versus me, the victor will only be you or me, and there will always be more of us to continue that fight.
While I doubt Islam's ability to deliver peace (given that they couldn't go one generation without finding a reason to fight amongst themselves), they do at least have the problem framed correctly: that there can only be peace when all are united around one consistent morality.
To be blunt with you Blue, I don't believe you're grasping the nuance of the point I'm making. You're a caveman; you see a problem, you hit the problem with a stick until it's no longer a problem; and that will work for you as long as the problem doesn't have a bigger stick. You don't care what history will say about your stick swinging and how it ended; and you certainly don't care about putting an end to all the stick swinging.
I do not believe for an instant that you believe the nihilists are right (that nothing is fundamentally moral or immoral). You wouldn't be here if you did.
If we "made it up" then the nihilists are right.
Look, this is a CHOICE. If you "know" morality is made up, then all your feelings about what is right and wrong are just you. If you "know" some things are fundamentally right or wrong, then that has to transcend you in order to be projected onto others, it can't just be something made up.
It is YOUR CHOICE to acknowledge a higher source of moral truth in order to give your moral judgements greater weight than your own disapproval. Only the divine can transcend you and encompass your enemies.
Yes, but the result will never be more than kratocracy.
Its a distinction between:
As long as it's literally just you versus me, the victor will only be you or me, and there will always be more of us to continue that fight.
While I doubt Islam's ability to deliver peace (given that they couldn't go one generation without finding a reason to fight amongst themselves), they do at least have the problem framed correctly: that there can only be peace when all are united around one consistent morality.
To be blunt with you Blue, I don't believe you're grasping the nuance of the point I'm making. You're a caveman; you see a problem, you hit the problem with a stick until it's no longer a problem; and that will work for you as long as the problem doesn't have a bigger stick. You don't care what history will say about your stick swinging and how it ended; and you certainly don't care about putting an end to all the stick swinging.