Figured I would ask the "brains trust", here, lol...
This is not my area of strength. Like, at all... Controversial perhaps, but, most of the time, I find computers (or rather, IT and "tech") to be... Immensely frustrating. I'm not stupid. I know the basics. I can do most things that most... "Normie" millennials can do. I just... I'm not a "build a computer from scratch" type person. Put it that way.
So when something goes wrong, like my current computer randomly losing a whole bunch of files, I... Attempt to solve it, but get increasingly frustrated when I can't. So here we are...
I'm not really a gamer, per se. I don't really watch movies on the computer, either (I know, weirdo, right?), aside from Youtube and the like (Vid Dailymotion, etc.).
I do, however, do an absolute fuck tonne of photography. Like, literally terabytes worth. Both mobile and D-SLR. In terms of "hobbies", or "interests", this, and music, are what I mainly use the computer for. Because my current computer is such an utter piece of shit (it's old, but has 1TB storage, which is a fair amount, for something a decade old), I spend... Literally days, just clearing data (photos, mainly) off it.
I also listen to a very large amount of music. Music is my passion. If I was better at it, I probably would have attempted to make a career out of it, by now. I do a little bit of mixing, but I would like to do more. If I had a better computer, I guess that's a thing I would do. Somehow the speakers on this old thing are really fucking good, though, so I would rather not lose that/have to make it external, lol... Though it's funny, because this computer is so fucked, that sometimes it crashes, when you try to load big playlists in Apple Music, lol...
Now for the more complicated stuff, which is sort of... Beyond, me. I'm not a graphics designer, but my degree, somewhat unfortunately, requires me to do a not significant amount of it. Which is shit, but so be it. Also, more broadly, a whole bunch of "digital drawing", and, hardest of all, for me personally, heaps of statistics-related programming. Heaps. Weeks worth. Which this computer simply cannot cope with (we mainly use R, if people have heard of that).
I also have to do a fuck-tonne of web-related shit, of course. Teams, fucking Blackboard, online interactive lectures, you name it. And then there's the video calling, and the more... "Academic" shit, like Endnote, and academic writing more broadly, which this computer simply cannot cope with, anymore...
Honestly, this computer is... So old, and deprecated, that I don't even think I can upgrade Office, on here, which leads to all sorts of fuckery.
Oh, and I nearly forgot: some degree of "ruggedness", would be good, because I do a surprisingly large amount of "field stuff", and I would rather the damn thing not be as fragile as this one, when I have to take it out there (obviously sparingly), lol...
So yeah. I'm a Mac "person". This is a Macbook. I mostly use an IPhone. I am not, however, "Windows illiterate". My last laptop was a Toshiba Satellite (when they were still making them), newer than this MacBook. But it was completely fucked, even from when I first got it, and ended up bricking itself, taking all my data with it, literally twice. And that, my friends, is why I spend so much time "backing up" (sadly). Having lost literally years of work, I just... Don't trust any device not to do the same, lol. So yeah. Would rather stick to the Mac "ecosystem", I think, but I can probably be swayed... Should I go for like "a custom build" (not by me, of course!!), do you think, for these sorts of needs, or do you think I can get by/away with "off the shelf"/ordered in..??
Just thought I would chuck this up, because, having lost... A not insignificant portion of data, this morning, for no apparent reason, I figure that, in desperate times, I... May as well ask some of "the brains trust" here, lol...
Thoughts, anyone??
Cheers in advance!
You're used to mac and not building your own computer so get a mac.
Big thing is to get an M1 processor mac with at least 16 GiB or more memory. These are absolutely a must, so no buying a used old Intel for cheap -- not worth it at any price. The other specs won't really matter much for you, but upgrade if you feel like it.
If you're on a budget I'd get a Mini or Air expanded to 16 GiB depending on how you want to work. These will be fine for anything you're going to use them for as long as you get 16 GiB ram not 8 GiB.
Your main concern is storage space. Apple storage is ridiculously priced so get the minimum SSD and a cooled, external enclosure and normal huge spinning drive in it for a Mini or probably better with a NAS network attached storage for a laptop (so no wires). You can just pick pretty much anything that looks okay on Amazon. Normal hard drive has to be formatted HFS+ not APFS and will be fine for your use case. Get another external drive and set up Time Machine so you don't lose files again. You can get a huge storage and backup for a few hundred dollars. An unlimited online backup like Backblaze is a good idea at ~$70/yr for peace of mind or spend $100/yr on a new hard drive and keep lots of backups - once you get into many GiB online backup slows down and takes a long time to finish uploading, but you leave in on and it eventually gets everything.
I would avoid the iMac because it's all-in-one and not repairable, so when the internal drive fails it's junk. Maybe you can use it as a monitor, idk, but to me it's just an annoyance and not worth it.
On the hard drives, any chance you could explain formats a little more, for me..
Because I have an empty, 300+GB BlueEye drive, that I must have bought for the Toshiba (see elsewhere), but it says it is “formatted for Windows MS-DOS”, or something, and will not let me edit or add anything, from the Mac…
Is that normal?? What do I look out for, when buying one, apart from what you already said..?
I have a few LaCie HDDs. Generally they’re about a terabyte (yes, this is how quickly I go through storage, but they’re also super fragile, so a couple just… Stopped working), and at least two were formatted with separate Mac and Windows compartments…
I generally just used the Mac compartment, so never really thought about that in great detail, tbh…
But yeah, the problem with those is that they’re so damn fragile, that even if the USB connection is loose for a second, even if you aren’t transferring anything at the time, if they haven’t been ejected yet, they tend to fry, and lose data…
Which, as you can imagine, is the worst feeling, lol…
Normal for Apple... they just don't want it easy to work with Windows, so can only read Windows' NTFS filesystem.
Apple uses APFS but it's only for solid state drives, and if you use it on a spinning hard drive it'll be complete dogshit. They have older HFS+ for spinning hard drives. Any drive can be erased and reset to a different filesystem using Disk Utility or whatever it's called on mac.
Yeah, my current (old) 8GIG Intel Ram is so appallingly bad it’s not even funny (on the MacBook), but that’s not surprising, of course, lol…
Apparently (I forgot about this), I need to consider the damn CPU fan, because the one on the MacBook is literally always struggling…
In my limited understanding of this shit, that would be because the CPU just isn’t coping, with even basic shit, yeah?
So if I simply get one that works properly, that shouldn’t be so much of a problem, at least for the first few years, right? Lol…
I know that’s super basic, but I honestly forgot to mention it!
The fan is so loud, on the current one, that you can frequently hear it from the next (connected) room over… It’s THAT bad, lol…
So an, uhh… Less noisy computer would almost literally be life changing, ha!
Pretty sure even the cheapest M1 should be fine so it's just screen size and whatever else. Fan probably you won't ever hear even when you're doing your matrix maths.
Here's a thought for you, what are you going to do with your old laptop? If it's one with an ethernet port you could plug it directly into the wifi, attach whatever usb drives, and share them using whatever mac sharing is built in. I don't have a mac so I can't say how that is done exactly.
Then you just get one good connection to a usb hub, never jostle the wires, and you're good. Have all your files available while you're at home, sit in front of the tv or whatever with no wires. On the go you have your 256 GiB built-in, or maybe you get a larger size if needed. That might work for you depending on how you plan to use the thing. It'd be a little slow depending on how fast your wifi router is, but you might not even notice except when doing a backup or sync maybe. If it doesn't have ethernet to plug in directly then it has to go twice on wifi which would slow it down by half.
The thing I'm not sure about is how you get Photos / Movies to use a network drive. Sure it can be done, but Apple tends to put everything on the main drive and just expect you to fork over the dough.