Whenever a loon starts telling you about how the precious land of the Indians was stolen by colonial settlers, ask in puzzlement if she thinks that indigenous people have more rights than others.
She will say yes.
"So Europeans have more rights to Europe than do the immigrant Muslims and blacks?"
Sounds great. Remember that the point is not to persuade the cultist. It is impossible to persuade a cultist. It is to strip him of the protection of mainstream opinion. By moving from "Indians have more rights because they were indigenous" (which will have some mainstream support) and forcing him into a lose-lose position, you can win any argument with him, even if he does not acknowledge it.
Whenever a loon starts telling you about how the precious land of the Indians was stolen by colonial settlers, ask in puzzlement if she thinks that indigenous people have more rights than others.
She will say yes.
"So Europeans have more rights to Europe than do the immigrant Muslims and blacks?"
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
Sounds great. Remember that the point is not to persuade the cultist. It is impossible to persuade a cultist. It is to strip him of the protection of mainstream opinion. By moving from "Indians have more rights because they were indigenous" (which will have some mainstream support) and forcing him into a lose-lose position, you can win any argument with him, even if he does not acknowledge it.