Regardless of how one feels about marriage and how we define it, let's ask a more pertinent question: Why does anyone need a bureaucracy's permission to validate one's relationships? Getting a marriage license from the government is a relatively new thing, historically speaking. Clearly, it was a mistake.
Despite being in the NYT, this is worth a quick read:
Why does anyone need a bureaucracy's permission to validate one's relationships?
Because your marriage isn't just an agreement between you and your spouse. It also creates obligations elsewhere, like granting you visitation rights and taxation benefits. And it's not a mistake for the government to promote the one relationship best suited to perpetuating society and discourage those that cause social strife.
You are putting the cart before the horse. Because gov got involved in marriage, now all these other entanglements have been tacked on. I get that, but it isn't my question. You need to answer why exactly government should make all marriages illegal except for the ones they deem to be legal. Where does this right spring from? What justification does the gov have for removing people right to free association and marriage?
Regardless of how one feels about marriage and how we define it, let's ask a more pertinent question: Why does anyone need a bureaucracy's permission to validate one's relationships? Getting a marriage license from the government is a relatively new thing, historically speaking. Clearly, it was a mistake.
Despite being in the NYT, this is worth a quick read:
https://archive.ph/uGTeq
Because your marriage isn't just an agreement between you and your spouse. It also creates obligations elsewhere, like granting you visitation rights and taxation benefits. And it's not a mistake for the government to promote the one relationship best suited to perpetuating society and discourage those that cause social strife.
You are putting the cart before the horse. Because gov got involved in marriage, now all these other entanglements have been tacked on. I get that, but it isn't my question. You need to answer why exactly government should make all marriages illegal except for the ones they deem to be legal. Where does this right spring from? What justification does the gov have for removing people right to free association and marriage?