Why are you quoting only statistics about Jewish ownership of 50+ slaves / plantations?
I can't see all the claims that have been made in this thread, thanks to excess moderation. But I'm going to guess that the claims were along the same lines as others I've heard, such as: "There were a lot more Jewish slave owners than white, but they were almost entirely city dwellers with 1 or 2 house slaves. Meanwhile, there were fewer white slave owners, but they frequently owned massive plantations with hundreds of slaves. In other words, there were more Jewish slave owners, but more slaves were owned by Whites."
Your counterpoints don't contradict that claim. But if the claim is true, then your points come across as deliberately calculated to paint Jews in the best possible light.
So my question is, what's going on here? Was there a different claim being made, which you're points actually contradict? Do you have evidence that the claim in assuming was made is false? Why did you feel the need to limit your stats to owners of 50+ slaves, as if only that number is relevant?
Why are you quoting only statistics about Jewish ownership of 50+ slaves / plantations?
I can't see all the claims that have been made in this thread, thanks to excess moderation. But I'm going to guess that the claims were along the same lines as others I've heard, such as: "There were a lot more Jewish slave owners than white, but they were almost entirely city dwellers with 1 or 2 house slaves. Meanwhile, there were fewer white slave owners, but they frequently owned massive plantations with hundreds of slaves. In other words, there were more Jewish slave owners, but more slaves were owned by Whites."
Your counterpoints don't contradict that claim. But if the claim is true, then your points come across as deliberately calculated to paint Jews in the best possible light.
So my question is, what's going on here? Was there a different claim being made, which you're points actually contradict? Do you have evidence that the claim in assuming was made is false? Why did you feel the need to limit your stats to owners of 50+ slaves, as if only that number is relevant?
Comment Reported for: Rule 16 - Identity Attacks
Comment Approved: This doesn't do that.
Read the links I shared.