Today we will discuss which games should win our award for "Best Adventure", "Strongest Anti-Communist Stance", and who should receive our "Gone Home" award for the most Overpriced Piece of Shit!
Please consider what you would like to argue should be the winning item for each of the passing categories.
Additionally, consider who you would like to nominate as your electors. You may choose 3 electors to cast votes for you on your behalf. Persuade them as necessary. You may choose yourself once. The top 12 most nominated electors will assemble as our electoral tribunal, and will vote on the final categories. Feel free to message me directly with your nomination, or comment your nominations publicly. The electors are allowed to vote their own conscience.
Previous Discussions:
Do you have a different nomination?
For me, personally though I'll be in the vast minority, is Red Dead Redemption 2.
I am no fan of the Cyberpunk genre, but I love western games. I've played COJ: Gunslinger many times. I bought a 35" 21:9 monitor specifically in anticipation of RDR2.
But here I am, really digging Cyberpunk, but I quit RDR2 at Chapter 4 or 5.
What a fucking slog. Shitty writing. Characters I could never care enough about to give a damn. Cliches. Ham handed plot-line forcing ridiculous mission setups. NPC mission character's dialogue often verbal diarrhea the 'writers' just pull out of their ass.
I came to realize, Rockstar games are designed by kids for kids that like to do stupid shit. Of any age. An open world to do stupid shit in.
Hell, I love open world games. Far Cry 3-5, Blood Dragon, Primal, New Dawn, AC Black Flag through Valhalla. Mad Max. I even enjoyed Rage 2. Witcher 3, of course. Finished them all.
But here I was, a game I was anticipating more than any for the past three years, but I just couldn't keep going.
Hell, I'm not even a story guy. I find most game's stories cliched and predictable. I'm usually laughing at the story when I do pay attention. If you grew up on classic literature you likely understand this. If you grew up on Star Wars and Michael Bay... eh. To me, it's the difference between 'The Twilight Zone' and 'The X-Files'.
<trying to keep the bit below somewhat spoiler free>
But I know what the #1 issue was for me and likely resulted in my viewing a lot more of the game from a negative perspective. Because it made getting through it painful for me, because they just kept making it so obvious he was a evil person and I could predict the outcome of the game. Over and over.
I think where it really went south was when you had to 'liberate' him and then tag along for the Holocaust. I would have blown his fucking brains out. But oh no, you have to continue to endure it. And at that point, I also liked the gang less, and I really wasn't that impressed in the first place.
This is cheap manipulation that the utes of today might need to be so obvious so they fucking 'get it', but I don't. It was just heavy-handed, shitty writing. Give me a little subtlety here and there please! I'd like the challenge of catching it.
Tangent: I'm responding to the 'nomination' but it would be disingenuous of me to claim it is "the most overpriced piece of shit" for others though. Hell even for me, I just couldn't get into it, but there is a LOT of game there. And a lot that is very well done. The world and atmosphere.
Although, to counter that, the bugs on PC are ridiculous. That's pretty much what the PCRedDead Reddit is all about, in the end.