Win / KotakuInAction2
KotakuInAction2
Sign In
DEFAULT COMMUNITIES All General AskWin Funny Technology Animals Sports Gaming DIY Health Positive Privacy
Reason: None provided.

Your post is very reasonable. However, you need to consider that we're talking about a meme. A meme is a form of communication that is intrinsically snappy, hyperbolic, and due to its format it can only give you a little nugget of information. A redpill, if you will. Its purpose is to trigger curiosity and prompt the viewer to do further research.

The Jewish question is an extremely complex topic, that will take you through politics, history, philosophy, and religion. You cannot expect a single meme to convince you of even a small aspect of the Jewish question. To acquire true knowledge, you must read books.

I really want to emphasize this point. One is not going to be able to understand how the world works by looking at memes, or even having discussions in this forum. The true source of knowledge must come from reading books. The forum is useful to refine arguments, check understandings, and have directions on what to research next; but it cannot be sufficient. I can tell quickly if I'm talking to someone who has opinions formed by reading books or if I'm talking to someone who only has a superficial knowledge acquired in online forums.

So while what you are saying is correct in a literal sense, in practice I think you're being too harsh in judging a meme. You wouldn't expect to learn everything about a topic by reading e.g. a newspaper article, would you? The claim of the meme "every single aspect of feminism is Jewish" is correct; it just doesn't have enough space to completely argue the case. That's up to the viewer to do his homeworks.

And in case you're wondering, here's a good reading list to understand the Jewish Question. For example, the full explanation of the claim "Jews have opened the floodgates to mass immigration" is in the book The Culture of Critique. I'm afraid you'll need to read the whole book to understand the justifications for that statement; I can't put the content of a whole book into a meme.

1 year ago
1 score
Reason: None provided.

Your post is very reasonable. However, you need to consider that we're talking about a meme. A meme is a form of communication that is intrinsically snappy, hyperbolic, and due to its format it can only give you a little nugget of information. A redpill, if you will. Its purpose is to trigger curiosity and prompt the viewer to do further research.

The Jewish question is an extremely complex topic, that will take you through politics, history, philosophy, and religion. You cannot expect a single meme to convince you of even a small aspect of the Jewish question. To acquire true knowledge, you must read books.

I really want to emphasize this point. One is not going to be able to understand how the world works by looking at memes, or even having discussions in this forum. The true source of knowledge must come from reading books. The forum is useful to refine arguments, check understandings, and have directions on what to research next; but it cannot be sufficient. I can tell quickly if I'm talking to someone who has opinions formed by reading books or if I'm talking to someone who only has a superficial knowledge acquire in online forums.

So while what you are saying is correct in a literal sense, in practice I think you're being too harsh in judging a meme. You wouldn't expect to learn everything about a topic by reading e.g. a newspaper article, would you? The claim of the meme "every single aspect of feminism is Jewish" is correct; it just doesn't have enough space to completely argue the case. That's up to the viewer to do his homeworks.

And in case you're wondering, here's a good reading list to understand the Jewish Question. For example, the full explanation of the claim "Jews have opened the floodgates to mass immigration" is in the book The Culture of Critique. I'm afraid you'll need to read the whole book to understand the justifications for that statement; I can't put the content of a whole book into a meme.

1 year ago
1 score
Reason: None provided.

Your post is very reasonable. However, you need to consider that we're talking about a meme. A meme is a form of communication that is intrinsically snappy, hyperbolic, and due to its format it can only give you a little nugget of information. A redpill, if you will. Its purpose is to trigger curiosity and prompt the viewer to do further research.

The Jewish question is an extremely complex topic, that will take you through politics, history, philosophy, and religion. You cannot expect a single meme to convince you of even a small aspect of the Jewish question. To acquire true knowledge, you must read books.

I really want to emphasize this point. One is not going to be able to understand how the world works by looking at memes, or even having discussions in this forum. The true source of knowledge must come from reading books. The forum is useful to refine arguments, check understandings, and have directions on what to research next; but it cannot be sufficient. I can tell quickly if I'm talking to someone who has opinions formed by reading books or if I'm talking to someone who only has a superficial knowledge acquire in online forums.

So while what you are saying is correct in a literal sense, in practice I think you're being too harsh in judging a meme. You wouldn't expect to learn everything about a topic by reading e.g. a newspaper article, would you? The claim of the meme "every single aspect of feminism is Jewish" is correct; it just doesn't have enough space to completely argue the case. That's up to the viewer to do his homeworks.

And in case you're wondering, here's a good reading list to understand the Jewish Question. For example, the full explanation of the claim "Jews have opened the floodgates to mass immigration" is in the book The Culture of Critique. I'm afraid you'll need to read the whole book to understand the justifications for that statement, I can't put it in a meme.

1 year ago
1 score
Reason: Original

Your post is very reasonable. However, you need to consider that we're talking about a meme. A meme is a form of communication that is intrinsically snappy, hyperbolic, and due to its format it can only give you a little nugget of information. A redpill, if you will. Its purpose is to trigger curiosity and prompt the viewer to do further research.

The Jewish question is an extremely complex topic, that will take you through politics, history, philosophy, and religion. You cannot expect a single meme to convince you of even a small aspect of the Jewish question. To acquire true knowledge, you must read books.

I really want to emphasize this point. One is not going to be able to understand how the world works by looking at memes, or even having discussions in this forum. The true source of knowledge must come from reading books. The forum is useful to refine arguments, check understandings, and have directions on what to research next; but it cannot be sufficient. I can tell quickly if I'm talking to someone who has opinions formed by reading books or if I'm talking to someone who only has a superficial knowledge acquire in online forums.

So while what you are saying is correct in a literal sense, in practice I think you're being too harsh in judging a meme. You wouldn't expect to learn everything about a topic by reading e.g. a newspaper article, would you? The claim of the meme "every single aspect of feminism is Jewish" is correct; it just doesn't have enough space to completely argue the case. That's up to the viewer to do his homeworks.

And in case you're wondering, here's a good reading list to understand the Jewish Question.

1 year ago
1 score