Starting from the left like some western normie:

Code Geass. (dot)hack. Evangelion. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya [needs proper watch order!]. (Text break). Clannad. K-on. SOUL EATER. A Certain Scientific Railgun [A Certain Magical Index is the first entry in this series, look up a timeline, so don't know why they went with the sequel].

Bottom row:

Sorry, these are apparently gatekept from the normies. Since I disagree with Highschool Of The Dead being in this tier, I'll mention that one, but according to the infographic I'm not allowed to give these away.

Some of the "fading memory" ones have had seasons more recent than the "The new hotness", so I'm not sure of OP's chronological sense. Has Stein's Gate imparted upon them some unknowable future?

Starting from the left like some western normie:

Code Geass. (dot)hack. Evangelion. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. (Text break). Clannad. K-on. SOUL EATER. A Certain Scientific Railgun [A Certain Magical Index is the first entry in this series, look up a timeline, so don't know why they went with the sequel].

Bottom row:

Sorry, these are apparently gatekept from the normies. Since I disagree with Highschool Of The Dead being in this tier, I'll mention that one, but according to the infographic I'm not allowed to give these away.

Some of the "fading memory" ones have had seasons more recent than the "The new hotness", so I'm not sure of OP's chronological sense. Has Stein's Gate imparted upon them some unknowable future?