How the fuck can the jury find in both their favors? The jury found that Heard made false accusations of abuse. So it explicitly found that Depp was telling the truth when he called her a liar, which means they should have found Depp not liable for defamation. I understand how suits/countersuits work but given the facts of this situation they should have found in favor of one or the other. They're contradicting themselves here.

How the fuck can the jury find in both their favors? The jury found that Heard made false accusations of abuse. So it explicitly found that Depp was telling the truth when he called her a liar, which means they should have found Depp not liable for defamation. I understand how suits/countersuits work but given the facts of this situation they should have for one or the other. They're contradicting themselves here.