In fact this proposal is pretty much the polar opposite of what we should want - they are saying "Yeah as long as you play ball and do what we say you're safe", codifying the current defacto system of control.

In fact this proposal is pretty much the polar opposite of what we should want - no moderation (curation) of content at all unless you (the editor) want to be held responsible for all content. Whereas they are saying "Yeah as long as you play ball and do what we say you're safe", codifying the current defacto system of control.